CREATIVITY, THE MAGIC SYNTHESIS

Silvano Arieti

 

The stages of creativity:

 

A.    Primary:     (Right brain) - a non-judgmental, non-disciplined playing with images, symbols, inner expressions of our inner lives.  (Memory, traces of past perceptions, subjective experiences and impressions). Images are the "first germ of creativity" and give birth to intuition and empathy.

 

B.    Secondary: (Left brain) - corresponds to conscious cognition or to Aristotelian logic - a process of choosing, deciding and putting order and form into our imaginings.

 

C.    Tertiary:    The marriage - the sum of the other processes which is greater than the sum of the parts; and the ability to differentiate SIMILARITIES from manifold experience.

 

D.   Fourth:      The artist knows he is an artist when another person says honestly "You have touched me" or "You have named my experience".  In this way all energy becomes connected again and the artist's ultimate vocation, to return energy to the universe by way of transformed matter, is accomplished.

                                           

- - - - - - -

 

A classical creativity description is the following 4 stage process (source: Joseph Wallas):

 

Preparation        - all the preliminary analysis, thinking;

 

Incubation          - letting the project 'cook', sleeping on it (maybe for years);

 

Illumination        - the insight/hunch/intuition and feeling (perhaps seeing inductive similarities to other processes or systems which could work);

 

Verification         - critical evaluation by the innovator and others of his work. 

 

(Jung would suggest that, in the 3rd stage - for the visionary, the "solution" does not originate in the lessons of life but from timeless depth - the collective unconscious).

- - - - - - -

 

Nine socio-cultural creativogenic factors:

 

1. Availability of cultural means.

2. Openness to cultural stimuli.

3. Stress on 'becoming' and not just on 'being'.

4. Free access to all cultural media for all citizens, without discrimination.

5. Freedom (or at least minimal discrimination after earlier severe oppression/exclusion).

6. Exposure to different or even contrasting cultural stimuli.

7. Tolerance for diverging views.

8. Interaction of significant persons.

9. Promotion of incentives and rewards.

- - - - - - -

 

Twelve basic characteristics of creative people (source:  Frank Barron)

 

  1. They are more observant.

  2. They express only part-truths.

  3. In addition to seeing things as others do, they see things others do not.

  4. They are independent in their cognitive faculties, which they value highly.

  5. They are motivated by their talent and values.

  6. They are more capable of holding many ideas at once, and comparing more ideas, hence making a richer synthesis.

  7. They have more sexual drive and are more vigorous from a physical point of view, and more sensitive (Arieti qualifies this point, noting examples of many creative people    who were not robust).

  8. They have more complex lives and see a more complex universe.

  9. They become more aware of unconscious motives and fantasy life.

10. They have strong egos that permit them to regress and then return to normality.

11. They allow the distinction between subject and object to disappear for certain periods of time, as in love and mysticism.

12. The objective freedom of their organism is at a maximum, and their creativity is a function of objective freedom.

- - - - - - -

 

Attitudes and conditions for fostering creativity:

 

1. Aloneness: the ability to be alone for a few hours, so as to listen to one's inner self, to come in contact with one's basic resources and with some manifestations of the primary right brain process.  (It is highly doubtful that an original    idea came from a team).

2. Inactivity: too much routine stifles mental activity. Periodic rest is necessary.

3. Daydreaming: a source of fantasy life that may open up the new    realms of growth and discovery.

4. Free Thinking: not free-association, but rather allowing one's mind to roam in an unrestrained, unorganized way.

5. One should Be in a State of Readiness for Catching Similarities - "synectics" - the drawing together of different, apparently irrelevant elements.

6. Gullibility: similar as in brainstorming, ruling out self-criticism of ideas and insights and suspending judgment for a certain period of time; a willingness to explore everything; to be open, naive, innocent before rejecting anything.  One is gullible only to the extent of not discarding insights indiscriminately.  One's final acceptance or rejection of an     insight would depend on one's secondary-process (left-brain) mechanisms.

7. Remembrance and inner replaying of past traumatic events: the creative person must be able to transcend his own subjective involvement or his work will not have universal significance or general resonance.  Conflict and its resolution are important as motivation and for content. [An analogy to the Buddhist Vipassana process of detachment of emotion from memory experience for insight.]

8. Alertness and Discipline: to enable the individual to maintain sufficient 

awareness to recognize the creative 'key'.

 

- - - - - - -

 

Endocepts (endo = Greek "inside") are cognitions which occur without representation - not expressed in images, words, thoughts or actions of any kind - an internal, private occurrence - distinguished from concepts (representations which can be expressed to other people).  Endocepts are non-verbal, unconscious or preconscious cognitions - the Primary process; concepts of everyday reality would be the Secondary process; the Tertiary process could result, creatively, in accordance with Systems Theory processes ("seeing" patterns/similarities, systematically).

 

- - - - - - -

 

The limitations of one's consciousness do not limit the severity of one's conscience.  Eg. Oedipus Rex can be said to portray the relation between good and evil, or between truth and illusion (or knowledge and ignorance).  Oedipus commits evil because HE DOES NOT KNOW: he does not know that he is the killer of his father and he is the husband of his own mother - when he discovers the truth, he has to pay the penalty - he gives up the throne and blinds himself.  Since he would not "see" in a more abstract way, he feels he doesn't deserve to see.

 

- - - - - - -

 

In the case of major discoveries (Newton: apple/moon --   gravity), the concept of the new class is much more important than the recognition of a similarity: but the a priori mental grasping of the similarity is necessary to evoke the concept of class at the conscious level.

 

Perception is a mysterious phenomenon, inasmuch as it transforms a physical event (the stimulus) into a subjective experience.  It permits a conversion of matter to psyche.  Further, the psyche mirrors matter.  In visualization imagery we have a related phenomenon even when the stimulus is absent.  The image is a (creative) mirror of another mirror (perception). 

- - - - - -

 

Three basic modes of operation determine and structure our knowledge of the world:

1.    determines what IS and what IS NOT (it abstracts unities and groups from the manifold of the universe). 

2.    identifies by discovering similarities, or correspondences, and thereby permitting class formation (it abstracts the similarities between different unities). 

3.    infers the NOT-given from the given, and this inference (abstraction) leads to symbolization.  These modes (i.e. the structures of time and space) have to be "learned" by evolution itself from the external environment and then evolution transmits them from generation to generation.  The modes happen to fit the world because the hereditary depositories of our mental functions were selected for their evolutionary fitness.  Whatever mutation or mental structure did not fit was dropped from genetic transmission.

 

- - - - - - -

 

The creative person remains the keeper of the secret of what makes his personality creative - a secret he cannot reveal to himself or to others. What is not a secret is how it (creativity) unfolds, reaches conclusion, and what conditions facilitate its occurrence.

 

 

 

 

Keith and Marnie Elliott’s “REMEDY” Site

 

Home

Our Stories

The Sublime

Our World and Times

Book Reviews

Marnie's Images

The Journal

Gleanings

From The Writings Of. . .

Allegories